Best Dog Collars For Pulling: Reclaim The Walk!

Leash and ball icon

Collars By Meg Marrs 17 min read December 4, 2019 3 Comments

best dog collars harnesses for pulling
Ideal For:Recommended Collar
Owners who want the best all-around harnessRabbitgoo Dog Harness
Dogs who still pull with other no-pull leashesSporn No-Pull Dog Halter
Owners looking for the best value2 Hounds Design No-Pull Harness
Novice and first-time ownersPetSafe Easy Walk Harness
Dogs with unusual buildsPetSafe Gentle Leader Head Halter
Owners who want the most affordable optionCountry Brook Design Collar

Taking your dog for a walk is a great way to bond with your pet, as well as get them the exercise they need to stay calm, happy, and healthy.

However, some owners find themselves dreading and even avoiding walks with their dogs due to their pup’s pulling nature. A pulling dog is no fun to walk and can be very stressful.

The good news is that with the right collar, usage, and training, owners can reclaim the walk and make walks an enjoyable experience again.

We’ll point out some of the best dog harnesses and collars for pulling below, discuss the different types of harnesses and collars that prevent your dog from pulling, and explain the things you want to look for when making your choice.

So, read on to learn more about no-pull collars, or just check out our recommendations in the chart below if you’re in a hurry (just scroll down to see in-depth reviews of each harness or collar for pulling).

No-Pull Technology: How Do No-Pull Collars and Harnesses Work?

Manufacturers use a few different approaches when making no-pull collars and harnesses. That’s great for owners and their pets, as it means there are several different options you can choose from on the market.

However, each no-pull technology works a little differently, and you’ll want to make sure you select the best type for you and your pup.

We’ll discuss the three most common designs manufacturers use below.

Correction Collars

Correction collars are essentially designed to help train your pooch not to pull during walks.

They give you the opportunity to initiate some type of mildly unpleasant correction when your dog begins pulling or jerking on the leash. Chain collars, prong collars and martingale collars are all examples of correction-style collars.

But these types of collars must be used carefully, to avoid injuring your dog. They should be used under the guidance of a professional trainer, and they aren’t ideal for inexperienced owners.

They are also inappropriate for some breeds, such as those with short, “pushed in” faces or weak tracheas.

Compression Harnesses

Compression harnesses utilize a pretty nifty principle to stop your dog from pulling: They get tighter when your dog puts pressure on the leash. The harder your dog pulls, the tighter they squeeze.

Unlike correction collars, which can apply pressure on a dog’s neck, compression harnesses squeeze a dog’s rib cage. This means they’re less likely to cause injuries.

Compression-style harnesses are probably the best option for first-time dog owners, and they can be very effective when used correctly.

They’re also pretty comfortable for dogs to wear and they don’t look as harsh as correction collars to bystanders and people at the dog park.

Directional Collars and Harnesses

Directional collars and harnesses make it easy to redirect your dog’s attention and generally improve his on-leash behavior.

Most harnesses accomplish this via a simple trick — they feature a leash clip that sits between your dog’s front legs, rather than on his back.

This does a couple of things. Most notably, it prevents the harness from triggering the innate pulling instinct of dogs the way some back-clip harnesses do. Additionally, they make it easy to compromise your dog’s balance and get his attention.

Think about it this way: Dogs can use all of their strong muscle groups to pull forward, so harnesses that clip on the back force you to pull against your dog’s strongest muscles. But on the other hand, dogs can’t use their strongest muscle groups when pulled to the side.

Head halters are another type of directional harness. These tools work by wrapping around your dog’s head and muzzle, thereby making it easy to direct your dog’s attention where you want and put an end to pulling behavior.

Key Features of the Best Dog Collar For Pulling

Not all dog collars for pulling are made the same. Some may offer unique colors and designs, but do not offer any important functionality.

There are certain elements you’ll want to look for in a pulling dog collar to ensure that it is safe for your dog and functions as intended.

  • Soft Material. One of the most important features of an anti-pulling dog collar is the material it is made from. Soft material is best, such as mesh or wool, as it helps keep pressure off the dog. A rough collar can rub the dog too harshly and cause irritation. If your dog finds the collar uncomfortable, they may start to chew at the harness or collar, which will naturally prove problematic
  • Adjustable. It is also important that the pulling dog collar is adjustable. When it comes to anti-pulling harnesses, one size does not fit all. An adjustable collar ensures the fit is correct for the dog’s size and shape, and it is better if there are multiple adjustable points.
  • Quick-Release Buckle. A quick-release buckle allows you to get the collar off your dog quickly. This is useful when the dog is pulling away to get back inside the house, or in the case of an emergency.
  • Underbody Protection. Harnesses that only focus on protecting the chest do not eliminate all uncomfortable sensations your dog feels. Your dog’s underbody needs extra protection, such as wool material, to keep your dog’s legs from becoming sore.

The 6 Best Dog Collars For Pulling: Prevent the Pull!

Several brands of dog collars offer anti-pulling features. Here’s our quick guide for recommended collars to stop pulling. We’ll detail a few recommended options in detail below.

1. Rabbitgoo No-Pull Dog Harness

The Rabbitgoo Harness is a high-quality dog harness that features clips on the front and back. If you need to stop your dog from pulling, just clip his leash to the front clip and lead him wherever you need to go.

Details

  • 【 LARGE DOG HARNESS 】 - ★ Measuring Neck Girth: 16.1" - 23.2", Chest Girth: 20.5" - 36" ★....
  • 【 NO PULL, NO CHOKE 】- Our non-pulling dog harness is specially designed with 2 Metal Leash...
  • 【 EASY TO USE 】- This hassle-free overhead harness is easy to put on and take off with its 2...
  • 【 FULLY ADJUSTABLE 】- This adjustable harness features 4 easy Adjusting Straps around the body....

Features:

  • Easy to put on or take off. This harness features a “step-in” design, which makes it easy to get your dog ready for walks.
  • No-choke design. This vest helps spread any leash pressure across your dog’s shoulders, chest and back, rather than his neck.
  • Reflective straps. This harness features reflective straps which will help make you and your pooch visible to passing motorists.
  • Sturdy materials and design. This harness features heavy-duty materials and metal D-rings to ensure it holds up to your dog’s jerks, twists and pulls.
  • Suitable for dogs of all sizes. This harness is available in four different sizes, and each one features an adjustable strap, making it easy to get a great fit.
  • Back handle. The built-in back handle on this leash provides extra control when you need it.

PROS: Most owners who tried the Rabbitgoo No-Pull Harness were very pleased with their choice. Many owners reported that it helped stop their dog’s pulling very quickly, and the majority of owners found it to be durable and well made.

CONS: A few owners found it difficult to determine the proper size to buy (it appears that you should opt for the smaller size, if your pooch is a tweener).

2. PetSafe Easy Walk Dog Harness

The PetSafe Harness utilizes two different no-pull technologies, as it not only comes with a front clip, but it tightens when your dog pulls too. Simple to use and easy to put on, this is probably one of the best options for first-time dog owners.

Details

  • Vet and trainer recommended: Created by a veterinary behaviorist over 15 years ago, the easy walk...
  • Safe solution for pulling: Allows you to control light to moderate pulling and rests across your...
  • Quick and easy: Fit the harness on your dog in just a few minutes with the quick snap shoulder and...
  • 1 year chew damage replacement: If your pooch decides to turn the harness into a chew toy, we will...

Features:

  • Martingale Loop. The martingale loop found on the PetSafe Easy Walk Dog Harness helps stop the leash from twisting. This prevents a common problem in which dogs get tangled, causing them to pull and tug.
  • Front-Chest Leash. This harness uses a unique front-chest attachment, allowing you to steer your dog to the side and redirect his focus towards you when walking.
  • Soft Nylon. Made from soft, strong nylon for a comfortable fit.
  • Easy Snap Buckle. Features an easy on and off snap buckle on the dog’s shoulder and belly straps.
  • 4 Adjustment Points. This harness is made with 4 adjustment points. This ensures the fit is right for each dog, and that the harness sits comfortably on their bodies.
  • 8 Different Sizes. This harness comes in eight different sizes, with the most commonly bought size being the medium/large. Sizes range from petite for small dogs to extra large for bigger breeds.

PROS: Many owners agree this harness fits comfortably on their dogs and enjoy the range of sizes + multiple adjustable positions. Owners rave over how this harness transformed their walks, correcting their dog’s pulling without choking them.

CONS: Some owners say this harness is too narrow, especially in the leg area, making it rub against their dog’s fur too much.

3. 2 Hounds Design Freedom No-Pull Harness

The 2 Hounds Design No-Pull Harness also utilizes two different no-pull technologies to help improve your dog’s walking habits. It comes with a ring in the front to make it easy to alter your dog’s balance, and it also features a martingale-style loop, which provides gentle pressure on your dog’s chest and ribs when he pulls.

Details

  • Recommended by Whole Dog Journal, the VIN (Veterinary Information Network) and many dog trainers as...
  • Stop the pulling!: Attaching your leash to the martingale loop on the back will allow your dog to...
  • Comfortable and durable: The Freedom no-pull harness has a soft velvet lining on the strap that goes...
  • Chew warranty: The manufacturer will replace up to two chewed straps for just the cost of shipping....

Features:

  • Comes with a double-clasp leash. This not only increases the value of the harness, it makes it easy to use both the back and front clip simultaneously, giving unparalleled control of your pet.
  • Comfort. This harness features a soft velvet lining to prevent chaffing.
  • Comes with a chew warranty. The manufacturer will replace up to two straps if your dog chews through the harness (you will have to pay for shipping).
  • Fits dogs of all sizes. This harness comes in six different sizes, and some sizes are available with straps of varying widths.
  • Plenty of color options. You can get the 2 Hounds Design Harness in 21 different colors to match your pup’s personality!
  • Quick-release clips. This harness is easy to put on and take off, thanks to the quick-release clips that come with it.

PROS: Most owners were very happy with the 2 Hounds Design Harness and reported that it quickly put an end to leash pulling. It also seemed to be easy for most owners to use, and it typically fit dogs well.

CONS: A few owners complained about the price of this harness, but it isn’t that much more expensive than some other options, it’s effective, and it comes with a two-clip leash. These factors should offset its price tag for most owners.

4. Gentle Lead Dog Collar

The Gentle Lead Collar is a head-halter harness that is designed to help eliminate leash-pulling behaviors. It is also helpful for keeping your dog’s head up and attention focused where you want it during walks.

Details

  • Vet and trainer recommended: Created by a veterinary behaviorist over 30 years ago, the gentle...
  • Safe solution for pulling: Immediately, gently and safely controls unwanted behaviors like excessive...
  • Quick and easy to fit: Easily fit the headcollar on your dog in just a few minutes using the...
  • 1 year chew damage replacement: If your pooch decides to turn the harness into a chew toy, we will...

Features:

  • Several Sizes. This dog anti-pulling collar comes in five sizes, ranging from XS to XL.
  • Multiple Color Options. Available in seven colors, allowing you to choose a style that matches you and your pet’s personality!
  • Fully adjustable. Adjustable neck strap and nose loop allow you to create a custom fit for your canine.
  • Reduces Bad Behavior. This dog pulling collar is designed to prevent pulling, lunging, jumping, as well as anxiety and general aggression.
  • Comes With Instructions. This collar includes fitting instructions as well as a training guide and DVD.
  • Immediate Results. Collar is said to improve walks immediately, with many dogs acclimating and adjusting behavior within minutes.

PROS: The huge majority of owners rave about this collar’s ability to stop bad behavior and make walking large, powerful dogs much easier with the prevention of pulling.

CONS: Some owners note that they needed to desensitize their dog to the collar and that using it required a fair amount of training. Some dogs simply could not adjust to it, and a few even injured themselves during use. However, even critics note that while this dog collar will not be a good fit for everyone, for many it will do a great job of preventing pulling.

5. Country Brook Design Martingale Collar

The Country Brook Design Collar tightens when your dog pulls, but – like other martingale collars – it has built-in safety features, which prevent it from becoming too tight. Because it only fits around your dog’s neck, rather than his chest and shoulders like traditional harnesses do, it may be a better choice for dogs with unusual builds.

Details

  • 1 INCH WIDTH | Adjustable from 15 inch - 21 inch neck. Be sure to use our martingale sizing chart...
  • NO BUCKLE | Perfect for training, Martingale-style collars give you gentle control over your pet....
  • Personalize your pup with rich, fashionable colors and mirror like metal hardware. The classic style...
  • Silky soft nylon webbing means your dog will stay comfy. Adjustable so you can have the perfect fit....

Features:

  • Made in the USA. This collar is made in the USA and built to last.
  • Peace of mind. The Country Brook Design harness is engineered to be escape-proof, so you won’t have to worry about your pooch slipping free.
  • Plenty of color choices. This collar comes in 20 different colors to suit pups of all personalities!
  • Durable. This harness features a combination of aluminum and stainless-steel hardware, and colorfast dye to ensure it won’t fade or run when wet.
  • Different widths for different sizes. The small model comes with a ¾-inch-wide nylon strap, while the straps of the other sizes are all 1 inch wide.
  • Good for dogs of all sizes. You can get the Country Brook Design Collar in four different sizes, and each one is adjustable so that you can achieve a proper fit.

PROS:  The vast majority of owners who tried this harness were very happy with their choice. Most explained that it was very well-made and durable, and that it helped encourage their pooch to behave better during walks.

CONS: There were a few one-off problems noted by some owners (such as sharp edges), but these were relatively rare and usually easy to correct.

6. Sporn No-Pull Dog Halter

The Sporn Dog Halter is a unique dog-walking tool, that is somewhat similar to compression-style harnesses. However, rather than constricting around your dog’s chest, they apply pressure near his front legs to help stop him from pulling.

Product

$21.99

Rating

1,091 Reviews

Details

  • MATERIAL: Made of highest quality braided cord with nickel plated steel fasteners and strong nylon...
  • INNOVATIVE DESIGN: Just as you pull, restraints under the front leg makes the dog stop immediately....
  • EASY TO PUT ON: The ultimate combination of style and comfort which your little furry friend would...
  • NO MORE PULLING: Walk any dog without being pulled down by the street. With its innovative design...

Features:

  • Durable materials. The Sporn Dog Halter is made with quality braided cord, nickel plated steel fasteners, and strong nylon webbing.
  • Innovative design. Unlike compression-style harnesses, which “encourage” your dog to stop pulling, the Sporn Harness is designed to (gently) force your dog to stop in his tracks, as they put pressure on the front legs.  
  • No-choke design. Unlike some other no-pull harnesses and collars, the Sporn Halter will not place any pressure on your dog’s neck or throat.
  • Color options. You can get the Sporn No-Pull Harness in red, black, or blue.
  • Multiple sizes. The Sporn Halter is not only adjustable, but it comes in four different sizes too.
  • Lifetime guarantee. The Sporn Halter is backed by the manufacturer’s lifetime guarantee. If you aren’t happy with the harness, simply return it with your proof of purchase.

PROS: Generally speaking, the Sporn No-Pull Halter received very positive reviews from most owners, and it seemed to help stop most dogs from pulling on the leash. In fact, it seemed to work for many owners who’d found other types of harnesses ineffective.

CONS: While this harness seemed to work for most owners, a few appeared to have trouble putting it on properly. A small number of owners also expressed problems with the nylon fraying.

Harness vs. Collar for Pulling Dogs: Which Option Works Best?

Many owners wonder whether a collar or harness is better for stopping their pet’s pulling behavior.

Each device offers a different set of benefits and drawbacks, but generally speaking, harnesses are better and safer to use with pulling dogs.

A few of the most important reasons this is the case include:

  • Collars can cause neck injuries for dogs who pull.
  • Collars may make it difficult for pulling dogs to breathe, and they can even cause permanent damage.
  • Collars can cause pressure on the eyes of some dog breeds (such as pugs).
  • Some collars are easy for dogs to slip out of. 

By contrast, properly fitted harnesses are usually pretty secure, and they shouldn’t cause neck injuries or make it difficult for dogs to breathe.  Additionally, harnesses with clips in the front make it easy to disrupt a dog’s balance, which will make it easier to keep your dog’s attention and stop pulling behaviors pretty quickly.

Nevertheless, collars – especially correction-style collars, including chain collars, prong collars, slip collars and martingale collars – are sometimes a good option.

Just be sure that you always keep your dog’s health and safety in mind when making your choice, and work with a professional trainer if you aren’t able to correct your dog’s pulling habit in a reasonable length of time.

It’s also a good idea to discuss your choice with your vet, to ensure the collar or harness isn’t likely to cause an injury.

We’ve actually written about the harness vs. collar debate before, so be sure to check out our comprehensive guide on the subject to learn more.

No Pull Dog Harness

More Dog Collar and Harness Resources!

Pulling isn’t the only common challenge that dogs can present. Some exhibit problematic chewing behaviors, while others are escape artists, who can quickly slip free during walks.

Because collars and leashes are such important tools for all dogs, we’ve written extensively on the subject.

So, be sure to check out the links below to learn more about addressing specific leash, collar, and harness problems.

  • Loose-Leash Walking 101 – No matter what type of harness or collar you end up with, you’ll want to train your dog how to behave during walks. We’ll tell you exactly how to do so here.
  • Training Collars and Harnesses – Collars and leashes can make effective training tools if you pick the right style and use them correctly. Check out dog trainer and canine behavior expert Kayla Fratt’s recommendations and advice to learn more.
  • DIY Dog Collars – Are you a crafty owner who likes making your dog’s gear with our own hands? Check out this article to see four different collars you can make at home.
  • Correction Collars – If you are thinking about using a chain collar (choke chain), prong collar, martingale, or slip lead, check out our comprehensive review of the subject to learn more about the differences between each and tips for using them properly.
  • Light-Up Dog Collars – If you regularly walk your dog after dark, you must be careful to ensure that passing motorists can see you and your pooch from a mile away. Fortunately, there are a number of dog collars that feature LED lights to increase your dog’s visibility.
  • Best Dog Head Halters – We mentioned one of the best head halters around above, but there are other options on the market. Check out this article to see more options and learn a few tips for using these types of harnesses effectively.
  • Best Harnesses for Small Dogs – Small dogs often present a unique challenge for owners seeking a harness, as they’re often too small to use a conventional harness safely. But you can find seven great options for small dogs here.
  • Chew-Proof Harnesses – Some dogs simply love to get their teeth on anything they can, and this can include harnesses (and leashes too!). Check out this article to see five different options that should stand up to your canine’s chompers, as well as some general tips for using a harness with toothy terriers and power-chewing pit bulls.
  • Hiking Harnesses – If you’re the outdoorsy type, and you love taking your pup on wilderness adventures, you’ll definitely want to check out this article. Hiking and camping with dogs presents a few special challenges that you should consider when picking out a collar or harness.
  • Escape-Proof Harnesses – Some dogs (particularly lanky breeds, like greyhounds and whippets) are often able to slip free of most ordinary harnesses. Fortunately, there are a variety of harnesses that make it difficult for even the most Houdini-like hounds to do so.

Note that while preventing dog pulling is normally an admirable goal, you may also want to consider harnessing that pulling strength into canicross or bikejoring, if it interests you and your furry buddy.

Regardless, you’ll still want to teach your pup not to pull on regular walks, and for that, anti-pulling harnesses are a must!

What are you favorite dog collar to prevent pulling? Do you have any experience with the dog collar listed here? Share your thoughts in the comments!

citronella-dog-collar
Recommended For You

Citronella Bark Collars: How Do They Work + Which Are Best?

Written by

Meg Marrs

Meg Marrs is the Founder and Director of Marketing at K9 of Mine. She is a lifelong canine enthusiast and adores dogs of all shapes and sizes! She loves iced coffee, hammocks, and puppy-cuddling!

Dog

Join our pup pack!

Get tons of great dog training advice and tips about gear!

Mailbox

3 Comments

Leave a Comment

Name
Email Address
Comment
Elaine

I’ve never tried a harness or gentle leader on Haley, although I probably should have when she was younger and pulling like crazy. All of these look like great options!

Reply
Meghan

Thanks for commenting Elaine! With Benzy we actually would loop the leash around his waste since he was a pro at squirming out of normal collars, and that worked just fine. Current dog Lucy is a very polite walker so thankfully no need for special measures! 🙂

Reply
Carolyn

I have an American Bully 7 month keeping for grandson.He is stong and he pulls tremendously im 64 heath problem walking. He jumps on child

Reply

Also Worth Your Time