The 10 Most Comfortable Dog Collars: Keep Your Canine Comfy!

Leash and ball icon

Collars & Harnesses By Kate Brunotts 11 min read August 31, 2021

K9 of Mine is reader-supported, which means we may earn a small commission through products purchased using links on this page. Here’s how it works.
Super comfy dog collar

Collars are some of the most important pieces of pooch gear, and all dogs should wear one that’s fitted with appropriate ID tags to stay safe when outside the house. So, as owners, we should do whatever we can to ensure our pooches get to enjoy a super-comfy collar!

We’ll help you pick out one below, as we explain some of the things that’ll make a collar extremely comfortable for your canine companion. We’ll also identify a few of our favorite comfortable dog collars for your pup.

Most Comfortable Collars for Dogs: Quick Picks

  • #1 Soft Touch Leather Padded Collar [Most Comfortable Collar] — Made with naturally tanned, sheepskin leather and fitted with brass hardware, this premium-caliber collar is easily one of the most comfortable models on the market.
  • #2 Black Rhino Padded Collar [Best Mid-Tier Comfortable Collar] — Water-resistant, padded, and made with high-quality hardware, this is an excellent option for owners looking for the ideal combination of quality and affordability.
  • #3 Mighty Paw Padded Dog Collar [Most Affordable Comfy Collar] — Although it isn’t quite as nice as some of the other options on the market, this is a great option for cost-conscious owners.

What Makes a Dog Collar Comfortable?

characteristics of comfy collargs

Since your dog should be wearing a collar whenever he ventures outside your home (even if he’s wearing a harness), you’ll want to make sure his collar is comfortable enough to wear for extended periods of time. Here are a couple of factors that make a collar more pleasant for your pooch:

  • Wider may be better. You may want to opt for a wide dog collar since this design spreads out the pressure on your pup’s neck more evenly. 
  • Prioritize padding for your pup. Some collars feature padding to keep things comfy for your canine. 
  • Fido doesn’t like friction. Some materials like leather create less friction on your dog’s neck fur for a more comfortable fit. 
  • Invest in high-quality parts. In general, seeking out well-made collars reduces the risk of stitching, rivets, or other collar components irritating your dog’s skin. 
Match Your Dog’s Collar to the Occasion

Don’t forget to keep the purpose of your dog’s collar in mind when making a selection.

For example, ask yourself if you want a collar that’s good for day-to-day use, or if you’re just looking for one that’ll work for special occasions, such as an LED light-up collar for after-dark walks or fancy-schmancy decorated wedding dog collars.

The 10 Most Comfortable Dog Collars

Here are 10 of the most comfortable dog collars to keep Spot safe and feeling his best. 

1. Soft Touch Leather Padded Collar

Most Comfortable Canine Collar

This is a sponsored placement, in which an advertiser pays a fee to be featured in this article. Learn more

Soft Touch Leather Padded Collar

Soft Touch Leather Padded Collar

Premium 1.5-inch-wide sheepskin leather collar that’s backed by a lifetime warranty.

About: This classy genuine leather collar from Soft Touch is padded for your pup’s comfort. Made with all brass hardware, this collar has a D-ring for attaching a leash and a separate ring for dog tags to keep things perfectly in place for your pooch. 


  • Collar is perfect for neck sizes ranging from 11 to 25 inches
  • Buckle and D-ring are made out of solid brass for longevity and durability
  • Collar is 1.5 inches wide and comes in six different color varieties 
  • Sheepskin leather padding is ultra-soft for Spot’s skin
  • Leather is naturally tanned using no harsh chemicals
  • Soft Touch backs each collar with a lifetime guarantee


  • Classy, versatile design looks great and provides exceptional comfort
  • Collar is backed by the manufacturer’s lifetime guarantee
  • Leather is naturally tanned, providing additional peace of mind for owners
  • Owners reported excellent customer service


  • Real leather might not hold up well around water 
  • Though such complaints were rare, a few owners had difficulty with the D-ring holding up over time

2. Black Rhino Padded Collar

Most Comfortable Mid-Tier Dog Collar

This is a sponsored placement, in which an advertiser pays a fee to be featured in this article. Learn more

Black Rhino - The Comfort Collar Ultra Soft Neoprene Padded Dog Collar for All Breeds - Heavy Duty Adjustable Reflective Weatherproof (Medium, Aqua/Grey)

Black Rhino Padded Collar

Padded, water-resistant collar that provides a great combination of quality and price.

About: This padded collar from Black Rhino is a great choice for owners who want a comfy collar that’s a step above entry-level models, yet still reasonably priced. Made with neoprene padding, high-quality hardware, and reflective stitching, this collar will also help keep your pooch comfy, secure, and visible in low light conditions. 


  • Flexible sizing options for dog neck sizes ranging from 11 to 27 inches. 
  • Water-resistant collar is perfect for active dogs
  • Reflective stitching increases your dog’s visibility
  • Comes in five different colors to fit Fido’s personal sense of style 


  • Collar strikes a good balance between durability, quality, price, and comfort
  • Comes with most of the features common to more expensive collars 
  • Sharp-looking design is a nice bonus


  • Collar is only about an inch wide 
  • Some owners found that the buckle mechanism was tricky to use

3. Mighty Paw Padded Dog Collar

Most Affordable Comfy Collar

This is a sponsored placement, in which an advertiser pays a fee to be featured in this article. Learn more

Mighty Paw Dog Collar - Neoprene Padded - Reflective for Night Runs - Extra Comfort for Active Dogs - Comfortable Collar for Dogs - Padded Collar for All Dog Breeds - Running Dog Collar - Sport Collar

Mighty Paw Padded Dog Collar

Comfortable collar that features all the things you want at an affordable price.

About: This padded collar by Mighty Paw is an affordable, yet high-quality collar. Made from attractive, weather-resistant materials, this collar is perfect for keeping Fido comfortable while hiking, running, or just exploring the great outdoors. Additionally, the embedded neoprene padding provides a great combination of comfort and air flow. 


  • Flexible sizing options for necks ranging from 12 to 25 inches
  • Embedded reflective stitching to keep Spot safe
  • Built-in padding helps keep your canine comfortable
  • Separate loop for ID tags 
  • Available in several sizes and two colors


  • Durable, water-resistant design will hold up well for active dogs
  • Easy to take on in off with durable clip buckle
  • Most owners found that the material was comfy on  their dog’s skin


  • “Weather-resistant” does not mean “waterproof,” so this collar isn’t a great choice for swimmers
  • Some owners reported that the Velcro of the collar wore out over time 

4. Link AKC Collar

Most Comfortable Smart Dog Collar

This is a sponsored placement, in which an advertiser pays a fee to be featured in this article. Learn more

Link AKC Smart Dog Collar - GPS Location Tracker, Activity Monitor, and More, Large (KITTN03)

Link AKC Collar

A comfortable, high-quality waterproof tracking collar with an embedded GPS chip.

About: If your dog is a wanderer, the Link AKC collar is an excellent tool to keep him safe while still providing the comfort he deserves. This collar allows you to track your pooch via GPS and has a variety of other helpful features including light and sound alerts for nighttime walks, as well as temperature alerts for whenever your pooch is an environment that may be too hot or too cold. 


  • Durable waterproof collar comes in sizes ideal for necks ranging from 9 to 25 inches
  • Smartphone app allows you to track your dog in real time over your data plan
  • Collar includes LED lights and temperature alerts that can be toggled remotely
  • Collar is available in leather and “sport” styles
  • Excellent customer service


  • Perfect for pooch escape artists and general pet parent peace of mind
  • Waterproof design makes this collar usable in almost any environment
  • Pet parents were impressed with the accuracy of this collar’s tracking capabilities


  • GPS tracker needs to be charged to work reliably
  • Some owners found the GPS tracking somewhat spotty

5. Nylon Military Collar

Most Comfortable Extra-Wide Collar

This is a sponsored placement, in which an advertiser pays a fee to be featured in this article. Learn more

Nylon Military Collar

OneTigris Nylon Military Collar

Wide, cushioned nylon collar that evenly distributes the pressure on your dog’s neck.

About: This adjustable nylon collar from OneTigris is great for big or strong dogs, as it’s wide dimensions help spread the force out over a larger area than narrower collars do. This, combined with the collar’s padded inner lining, helps to keep your canine comfortable and safe. 


  • Appropriate for dogs with neck sizes ranging from 14 to 24 inches
  • Hook and loop panel allows you to customize the collar with patches
  • Padded collar features a solid metal D-ring and buckle
  • Collar comes in five neutral colors to suit your pup’s sense of style
  • Collar is 1.5 inches wide to spread out the pressure on your pup’s neck


  • Collar is optimized for canine comfort with padding and wide design
  • Collar is easily adjusted and can be customized with patches to show off your pup’s personality
  • Most owners found the collar strong and durable enough for long-term use


  • Some dogs didn’t seem to like  the nylon fabric
  • A few owners reported D-ring failures, but these complaints weren’t especially common

6. Velvet Dog Collar

Most Comfortable Collar for Fashion-Conscious Canines

This is a sponsored placement, in which an advertiser pays a fee to be featured in this article. Learn more

Bubblepup Dog Collar, Velvet Dog Collar, Classic Dog Collar Soft Comfortable Adjustable Collars for Dogs Small Medium Large

Bubblepup Velvet Dog Collar

Fashionable yet functional dog collar made of soft velvet and available in several colors.

About: This adorable dog collar from Bubblepup is not only great looking, but it’s also made out of velvet, so it won’t irritate your dog’s skin. Though it’s only 1 inch wide, this collar is still pretty sturdy and features a secure, easy-to-use, stainless steel buckle.  


  • Adorable collar is suitable for dog neck sizes ranging from 8 to 26 inches
  • Soft velvet design is comfy for your dog’s skin
  • Comes in four colors to match your pup’s personal style
  • Features a stainless steel buckle and D-ring
  • Reinforced and features double stitched seams


  • Collar is dog-gone adorable and perfect for posh pups
  • Velvet material shouldn’t irritate your dog’s neck
  • Available in sizes suitable for most dogs


  • May not be strong enough for really big or strong dogs
  • Velvet material will get dirty easily 

7. Padded Cushion Collar

Most Comfortable Breathable Collar

This is a sponsored placement, in which an advertiser pays a fee to be featured in this article. Learn more

Padded Cushion Collar 1 1

Chai’s Choice Padded Cushion Collar

Lightweight dog collar with soft, breathable mesh padding that provides a ton of airflow.

About: This padded collar from Chai’s Choice is made out of durable, lightweight nylon and features breathable mesh, making it ideal for dogs who’re prone to irritation. The flexible collar comes in sizes suitable for pint-sized pooches and big buddies alike, so you’re sure to find a comfortable fit for your four-footer. 


  • Reflective collar has sturdy stainless steel attachments
  • Breathable mesh padding is perfect for hot-spot-prone pups
  • Flexible sizing options ranging from 11 to 24 inches
  • Comes in 9 different color options 
  • Made by a veteran-owned company


  • This padded, breathable collar is perfect for dogs who live in warm areas
  • Reflective stitching makes for greater night visibility 
  • Offered in a number of colors, making it easy to match your pup’s style


  • A few owners found this collar difficult to put on or take off 
  • Some owners found that the collars run a bit on the large side when compared to the sizing chart 

8. Tactical Dog Collar

Most Comfortable Collar with a Handle

This is a sponsored placement, in which an advertiser pays a fee to be featured in this article. Learn more

Yunlep Adjustable Tactical Dog Collar Military Nylon Heavy Duty Metal Buckle with Control Handle for Dog Training(L,Coyote Brown)

Yunlep Tactical Dog Collar

Comfortable collar with an attached handle to provide additional control of your dog.

About: This military style dog collar from Yunlep is made out of nylon and heavy duty metal making it a durable, dependable dog collar. The collar measures 1.5 inches wide to help evenly distribute pressure on your pup’s neck, and it comes with an attached handle to provide maximum control of your canine. 


  • Durable collar comes in sizes ranging from 14 to 24.5 inches long
  • Comes in 4 neutral colors 
  • Heavy duty metal parts are designed to last 
  • 1.5-inch-wide collar reduces pressure for your pooch
  • Collar can be customized with patches or badges


  • Durable collar seemed to hold up well even for larger breeds
  • Attached handle is very convenient for dogs who require a bit more control
  • Great for large or strong dogs


  • Some users found that the black paint wears off of the metal buckle
  • Velcro strip may collect debris if not covered in patches

9. Neo Classic Collar

Most Comfortable Collar for Swimmers

This is a sponsored placement, in which an advertiser pays a fee to be featured in this article. Learn more

EzyDog Neo Classic Wide Neoprene No Stink Waterproof Dog Collar for Large Dogs - Reflective for Nighttime Safety and Padded for Comfort - Superior Durability and Easy to Clean (XX-Large, Black)

EzyDog Neo Classic Collar

Wide, waterproof, and made with reflective stitching, this collar is great for active pups.

About: This 1.75-inch wide dog collar from Ezydog has a truly waterproof design making it perfect for dogs who love to dog paddle. This sturdy collar also has reflective stitching designed to keep your pooch safe when walking at night. 


  • Fast drying neoprene is perfect for active dogs
  • Separate dog tag clip and D-ring 
  • One-time fit Velcro-based adjustment mechanism
  • Perfect for dog neck sizes ranging from 18 to 32 inches long
  • Reflective stitching is great for added safety


  • This is a sturdy collar that’s great for large dogs
  • Neoprene material is durable and ideal for swimming dogs 
  • One-time Velcro fit system is quite convenient


  • Not available in sizes appropriate for small dogs
  • Some owners didn’t like how large the logo was on this collar, but that’s an exceedingly minor complaint

10. Maximus Leather Dog Collar

Most Comfortable Collar for Big & Strong Breeds

This is a sponsored placement, in which an advertiser pays a fee to be featured in this article. Learn more

Bestia Maximus Genuine Leather Dog Collar, Large Breeds, Cane Corso, Rottweiler, Bullmastiff, Dogo, Quality Dog Collar, 100% Leather, Studded, L- XXL Size, 2.5 inch Wide. Padded. Made in Europe!

Maximus Leather Dog Collar

Cushioned leather dog collar that’s available in sizes large enough for the biggest breeds.

About: This stunning leather dog collar from Bestia is sure to turn heads with its beautiful, ornate design. Made from genuine leather and heavy-duty metal components, this leather dog collar is as durable as it is comfortable.


  • 100% leather collar with embedded padding
  • Large collar is suitable for dogs with neck sizes ranging from 16 to 30 inches
  • Sturdy metal buckle is secure and easy to adjust
  • Made in Europe with heavy duty metal parts  


  • High-quality dog collar that’s built to last
  • Eye-catching aesthetics were a hit with owners
  • Large and strong enough for mastiffs and other big breeds


  • Leather isn’t water resistant, so you’ll need to keep it dry
  • A bit expensive, but this kind of quality and durability always come at a price

Picking a Comfortable Dog Collar Is Only Part of the Battle: Sizing Is Important Too!

Don’t forget the importance of proper sizing when trying to choose a super-comfy collar for Cocoa.

After all, you don’t want to spend all this time looking for a comfortable collar only to select one that won’t fit your four-footer properly!

Doing so not only means the collar won’t be as comfortable as possible, it also means that the collar may actually rub your dog’s neck, leading to pretty serious discomfort.

Additionally, a poorly fitted collar may also allow your dog to slip loose and escape, which is pretty much the nightmare scenario for most owners.

make sure collar fits

For dogs who slip easily out of even well-fitting collars, consider getting a martingale dog collar or an escape-proof dog harness.

Not sure what size collar to get? We’ll share a couple of key guidelines for determining the correct collar size for your doggo below.

  • Use a seamstress’ tape to measure the circumference of your dog’s neck. If you don’t have one, just use a string or shoelace to mark the circumference of your pet’s neck and then measure the length of the string with a ruler. 
  • You’ll want to add an inch or two to this measurement to make sure it’s not too tight on your pooch. As a rule of thumb, a well-fitted collar should have enough space for you to slip in two fingers between your dog’s neck and the collar. This way, the collar is secure but not choking your dog. 
  • It’s also a good idea to measure the base of your dog’s head. Select a collar that fits within this measurement and your neck measurement to ensure that your collar of choice doesn’t slip off while in use. 


Our dogs deserve the absolute best, so there’s no exception when it comes to comfortable collars. Collars are an essential safety tool, so it’s paramount that your dog doesn’t mind wearing it for a couple of hours at a time. 

Has your canine tried any of these collars? How do you keep your pooch comfortable and content? We’d love to hear all about it in the comments below! 

Recommended For You

22 Epic, Creative, & Unique Dog Collars & Leashes

Written by

Kate Brunotts

Kate is a dog-loving content specialist with over a decade of canine-care experience. She is currently a professional dog walker and pet sitter, with previous experience working at the Heart of Chelsea Animal Hospital in Manhattan. When not spending time with four-footers, she can usually be found crafting top-notch dog-care articles that pet parents can trust. Kate loves dogs of all shapes and sizes, but Bernese Mountain Dogs hold a special place in her heart.


Join our pup pack!

Get tons of great dog training advice and tips about gear!


No Comments

Leave a Comment

Email Address

Also Worth Your Time